CELL PHONES
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
LAPTOPS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
CAMERAS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
» infoSync TV » Review Center
» CES 2009 » Expert guides
» RSS & Alerts » Ask The Editors
Home / Review Center / Cell phones / Bluetooth headsets
Stereo Bluetooth duel review: Etymotic Ety8 vs. Plantronics Pulsar 590aBy Jennifer Hooker, Monday 19 February 2007
 
These high-end headsets offer great sound without any of the hassle from wires. Which headset will reign supreme, and which will fall flat?

Review summary of the Plantronics Pulsar 590a:
Gallery »
Pros:
Cons:
%
POOR
Mediocre
Good
Very good
Excellent
Full review of the Plantronics Pulsar 590a:
Round 1: Design

Plantronics Pulsar 590a
Plantronics Pulsar 590a
Enlarge »
Etymotic Ety8
Etymotic Ety8
Enlarge »
Etymotic's Ety8 earbuds take an early lead in the style department. Its diminutive rectangular form factor was simple yet sleek, and most importantly lightweight at just 0.7 ounces. As a result, the Ety8 was easy to wear for long periods of time, and felt very stable during our tests, even when we vigorously shook our head. Size did matter for the Plantronics Pulsar 590a earbuds, which were rather large and clunky. The headset looks like your run-of-mill pair of over-the-ear headphones, dressed in generic sliver and black. The 590a tips the scales at 3.3 ounces, making long-term wear uncomfortable.

Winner: Etymotic Ety8

Round 2: Sound

Plantronics Pulsar 590a
Plantronics Pulsar 590a
Enlarge »
Etymotic Ety8
Etymotic Ety8
Enlarge »
You might think that this was a no-brainer category for the Ety8 headphones, which serve up amazing sound, with crisp, bright tones and a strong bass kick. However, they disappointingly don't include a microphone for taking calls -- after all, the Ety8's are aimed more at iPod users than cell chatters. So that leaves the door open for the Pulsar 590a headset, which supports all three Bluetooth profiles including hands-free, headset and stereo. But the Pulsar stumbles with its so-so sound quality; both calls and music sounded muffled to our ears, a far cry from the crystal-clear audio from the Etymotic headset. The final nail in the 590a's coffin is the on-the-ear design of its headphones, which allowed outside noise to leak in; the in-ear Etymotic headphones kept ambient sounds at bay.

Winner: Etymotic Ety8

Round 3: Setup and connectivity

Plantronics Pulsar 590a
Plantronics Pulsar 590a
Enlarge »
Etymotic Ety8
Etymotic Ety8
Enlarge »
Both headsets paired easily with our Samsung MM-A900, and each comes with a multi-colored LED indicator that clearly lets you know what mode you're in through colors and not flashing speeds. Etymotic offers an iPod adaptor that connects to the bottom of the music player -- nice, but it'll cost you $100 extra. Plantronics steals the category by bundling (at no extra cost) a Bluetooth adapter that connects to any device with a 3.5mm headphone jack, which includes all iPods (like the Shuffle), and just about any other MP3 player out there (such as the just-reviewed Samsung YP-K5).

Winner: Plantronics Pulsar 590a

And the winner is…

Though the Plantronics Pulsar 590a headset put up a good fight when in came to setup, it was no match for the Etymotic Ety8 earbuds in the design and sound departments. Overall, the 590a was quite bulky and heavy making them uncomfortable. The headset's sound was just about average. Though the Ety8 doesn't include a microphone for handling calls, we feel that its crystal clear sound will draw true audiophiles who are looking at stereo Bluetooth devices for their music capabilities.

Champion: Etymotic Ety8

Related products:

Plantronics Pulsar 590a    Similar models »
Score: 74% When: December 2006 Worth: $250
This headset boasts the ability to connect with your iPod or any other music player with a standard 3.5mm jack. Will the 590a have you singing its praises or crying foul?
Read »
Plantronics Pulsar 590a
Etymotic Ety8    Similar models »
Score: 79% When: December 2006 Worth: $200 - $300
Designed by the venerable high-end headphone maker, this Bluetooth headset costs a bundle and won’t handle your voice calls. But the Ety8 has an ace up its sleeve. Read our review for the scoop.
Read »
Etymotic Ety8
Best Bluetooth headsets
Name Score Price Carrier
C
Samsung SBH170 73% $120
Motorola S9 68% $45
Motorola H700 60% $120
Click here to see full and advanced chart »
 
 
 
CES & MACWORLD 2009
Follow our exclusive in-depth coverage »
RECOMMENDED
Bold vs. E71 vs. Epix vs. Treo 800w
 
Storm vs. iPhone 3G vs. Omnia vs. Touch Diamond
 
T-Mobile G1 vs. Xperia X1 vs. Touch Pro vs. AT&T Fuze
 
TOP STORIES
Sony Ericsson C510 Cyber-shot, W508 Walkman phones flirt with AT&T
 
LG Watch phone could be gesture controlled
 
Palm Pre and Palm WebOS in-depth look
Mobile Year In Review 2008
 
Best Smartphones of the Year
 
Best Cell Phones of the Year
Best Camera Phones
 
Best AT&T Phones of the Year
 
Best Verizon Wireless Phones
Best Sprint Phones of the Year
 
Best T-Mobile Phones of the Year
 
Best All-Touch Phones of the Year
CELL PHONE RESOURCE CENTER
Best phones
 
Expert guides
 
Ask the Editors
» Top 15
QWERTY phones
 
All-touch phones
 
Touchscreen phones
Business phones
 
Multimedia phones
 
Concept phones
3+ inch screen phones
 
Wi-Fi phones
 
More...
» Search (New!)
Search by cell phone features
» Manual comparison (New!)
Select up to 4 cell phones side-by-side
» By release
October 2008, November 2008, December 2008
» Top 15 by carrier
Unlocked, AT&T, Sprint, Verizon Wireless, T-Mobile, Helio, Alltel
» Top 15 by user type
Average Joe, Business users, Calling addicts, Fashion conscious users, Globetrotters, High-res addicts, Internet addicts, Multimedia enthusiasts, Music aficionados, Outdoor enthusiasts, TV addicts, Video lovers, More...
» Top 15 by brand
Apple, HTC, LG, Motorola, Nokia, BlackBerry, Samsung, Sony Ericsson Other
» Top 15 by platform
Palm OS, Symbian S60, Symbian UIQ, Windows Mobile
» Top 15 by cell phone type
Business smartphones, Multimedia smartphones
Consumer QWERTY phones, Multimedia phones
Concept phones
NOW IN PHONES
Sony Ericsson C510 Cyber-shot, W508 Walkman phones flirt with AT&T
 
LG Watch phone could be gesture controlled
 
Palm Pre and Palm WebOS in-depth look
 
Nokia E63 QWERTY smartphone gets official U.S. price tag
 
BlackBerry Curve 8900 for T-Mobile is thinnest BlackBerry to date
iPhone 3G gets OTA music downloads
Motorola MotoSurf A3100 social smartphone begs to be touched
Motorola Renew recyclable phone coming to T-Mobile
Next 25 stories
MUST READ
CELL PHONES
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
LAPTOPS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
CAMERAS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
MP3 players
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
INTERNET TABLETS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
GPS NAVIGATORS
HDTVs
CAMCORDERS
About us | Site map | How to advertise | Feedback | RSS Feeds | | Archive
Copyright 1999-2008 © infoSync World