CELL PHONES
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
SMARTPHONES
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
CAMERAS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
REVIEWS
» Cell phones
» Cameras
» Camcorders
» Archive » Product Guide
» Compare » Expert guides
» RSS & Alerts » Ask The Editors
Home / Review Center / /
Review: Palm Tungsten WBy Larry Garfield, Wednesday 26 March 2003
GALLERY
Enlarge
 
 
Palm believes in wireless. That's why it keeps trying to build wireless-data devices for the mass market. Larry Garfield looks at their fourth attempt and decides Palm has gotten it right... mostly.

Palm has been a big fan of wireless data for a long time. Its Palm VII was the first wireless data handheld for the mass market. Although the Palm VII and its successors the VIIx and i705 never sold especially well, Palm has not given up on the idea of always-on, always-online mobile devices. This time, however, they've moved from slow pager networks to the faster and more flexible GSM/GPRS network with the Palm Tungsten W. More than just heir apparent to Palm's continued push at the corporate and power mobile user, the Tungsten w is a good device in its own right. However, some of its components are a bit dated, and we find ourselves looking at the Tungsten W as a hint of what is to come.

The Tungsten W is Palm's fourth wireless data device
Design

The Tungsten W feels a bit large compared to some of the other thin-is-in devices, but in fact it is no larger than the extended Tungsten T. It measures 12.1 x 7.79 x 1.65 cm, and weighs 184 grams. Most of that extra weight is due to the battery. More on that later. The casing itself is a smooth gray plastic, with very smooth, sloping design.

The Tungsten W's screen is a 320x320 16-bit color TFT, of the same design as on the Tungsten T. It's not quite as bright as the Tungsten T, but it is still easily bright enough for regular use. It uses the PalmSource High-Density screen API, which is standard on all Palm OS 5 devices now as well. Colors are vivid and clear, as they should be, and the refresh rate is good with no ghosting.

The Tungsten W is the first Palm-branded device to forego a Graffiti area in favor of a thumbboard. The keys are in a QWERTY layout in three even rows, and every button is oval-shaped and slanted to the right, a layout licensed from Research In Motion. While it's not bad, frankly Palm could have done better than to license RIM's design. We find square or round keys easier to use, such as those found on the Sony CLIE PEG-TG50 or Sharp Zaurus. Another problem with the keyboard is that it lacks directional arrows, and in most applications the 5-way NavPad (see below) is not mapped to text directional characters. That makes writing long pieces of text a hassle, as moving about the text requires using the stylus or a fingernail. The key travel is good, and the keys have a good tactile feel to them.

A fourth row of keys includes a Blue Function key, Shift/Caps Lock, spacebar, Shortcut, and Home keys. The Home button is a single-press, as it should be, and the Menu button is Fn+Shortcut, an interesting and fairly good placement. Find is Fn+Caps. The top row of letters doubles as number keys, while nearly all other keys double for some punctuation charcter. There are still a few unusual characters that are not available via the keyboard by default. Unlike the novel character-list system of the Treo keyboards, Fn+Spacebar calls up an on-screen keyboard that allows access to all alphanumeric and symbolic characters. All the keys can also be individually remapped to any layout the user wishes, though layouts cannot be easily saved and shared. The shift and function keys are "sticky", that is, pressing and releasing the key will keep the shift function active for the next keystroke. Two-thumb typing is possible, but the slanted keys and non-staggered layout caught us hitting the wrong keys periodically. It's a good keyboard, but not stellar.

Beneath the keyboard are the usual four application buttons, which on the Tungsten W by default map to Date Book, Address Book, VersaMail, and "AT&T Wireless applications". The latter is a simple graphical menu with five items, Phone, SMS, Web, WAP, and Office Online. All are self-explanatory except for Office Online, which is an AT&T Wireless-specific service. All buttons are round and a bit small, but perfectly usable. The spacing is a bit wide for gaming, but that is not likely to be a common use for this model. Instead of a rocker, the Tungsten W features a smaller version of the superb Tungsten 5-way Navigator D-Pad found on the Tungsten T. We really hope that this NavPad makes it into every Palm OS device as soon as possible.
Best Phones
Name Score Price Carrier
C
Nokia N95 8GB NAM 83% $450Unlocked
Apple iPhone 3GS 83% $200AT&T
Nokia N86 82% $500Unlocked
Sprint Hero 81% $180Sprint
Motorola Droid 81% $200Verizon Wireless
HTC Droid Eris 81% $100Verizon Wireless
Samsung Moment 78% $180Sprint
Apple iPhone 3G 77% $100AT&T
RIM BlackBerry Tour 77% $200Verizon Wireless
HTC Touch Pro2 77% $350T-Mobile
Click here to see full and advanced chart »
 
 
 
HOTTEST
Smartphones
 
Cell Phones
 
Upcoming Smartphones
TOP STORIES
Best 8-megapixel camera phones
 
10 Hottest Verizon Wireless Phones
 
5 Best All-Touch Smartphones
Hottest Nokia Phones
 
5 Best Smartphones for Calling
 
Android Smartphone Comparison
10 Hottest Touchscreen Phones
 
Hottest Smartphones Set for November Release
 
Upcoming T-Mobile Phones
NEW CELL PHONE RELEASES
Samsung Behold II
RIM BlackBerry Bold 9700
Nokia N900
Nokia N97 mini
Motorola Droid
HTC Droid Eris
LG Chocolate Touch
Samsung Moment
RIM BlackBerry Storm 2
CELL PHONE RESOURCE CENTER
Expert Guides
 
Advanced Search
 
Side-by-Side
IN-DEPTH REVIEWS
Cell Phones & Smartphones
 
Digital Cameras
 
Camcorders
NOW IN PHONES
Best 8-megapixel camera phones
 
Gameloft Cuts Back Android Investment
 
Smartphone Leaks of the Week
 
10 Hottest Verizon Wireless Phones
 
Motorola Droid Is No Challenge Says Palm
Nokia Nseries Roadmap Explained
gPhone Is Likely Not Real
BlackBerry 9900 QWERTY Slider Coming in 2010?
Next 25 stories
MUST READ
CELL PHONES
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
SMARTPHONES
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
LAPTOPS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
CAMERAS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
INTERNET TABLETS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
GPS NAVIGATORS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
HDTVs
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
CAMCORDERS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
About us | Site map | How to advertise | Feedback | RSS Feeds | | Archive
Copyright 1999-2009 © infoSync World