CELL PHONES
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
» TV: Phones
LAPTOPS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
» TV: Laptops
CAMERAS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
» TV: Cameras
» infoSync TV » Review Center
» Digital Frontier » Expert guides
» RSS & Alerts » Ask The Editors
Home / Cell phones
Nokia E61 vs O2 XDA Exec: Battle of the Business phonesBy Jørgen Sundgot, 15 June 2006
GALLERY
Nokia E61
Enlarge
Nokia E61
Enlarge
Nokia E61
Enlarge
Nokia E61
Enlarge
Nokia E61
Enlarge
Nokia's most capable business phone to date goes head-to-head with the king of the Windows Mobile hill; it's the E61 versus the O2 XDA Exec - tag along to see these heavyweights duke it out!

O2 XDA Exec
O2 XDA Exec
Enlarge »
Nokia E61
Nokia E61
Enlarge »
A mere two years ago, who would have thought that Microsoft's Windows Mobile device platform would climb to a position where it would be compared with what the best of what the planet's most prolific handset maker - Nokia - has to offer from its Symbian OS based portfolio? With no further ado; the moment has arrived for us to pit the pinnacles of either platform against one another - and you might be surprised by the winner.

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder

Nokia E61
Nokia E61
Enlarge »
O2 XDA Exec
O2 XDA Exec
Enlarge »
The most visible difference between the two devices is their form factor. Perhaps best described as a hulking behemoth, the clamshell Exec has nothing on Nokia's comparably-sleek E61 candybar design - but then the Exec also offers a 20% larger, double-the resolution display and a thumbboard that's nearly twice the size of that of the E61. This allows for slightly increasing typing speeds, but the greatest benefit is the lowered concentration level required during typing. As for the screen, there's no denying the Exec can display more information than the E61, yet the latter still copes very well for the vast majority of tasks.

O2 XDA Exec
O2 XDA Exec
Enlarge »
Nokia E61
Nokia E61
Enlarge »
3G, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, memory expansion and USB; although the two devices match each other blow by blow in the connectivity department, the E61 wins by a slight margin courtesy of better reception, transfer speeds and voice call quality. Its lack of 3G video calling might bother a few souls, but the trade-off is well worth it. Far worse is the poor out-of-box synchronization support of the E61, which - in the name of fairness - has been improved through the launch of an Exchange ActiveSync application since our review, but still lags behind that of the excellent local and groupware support of the Exec.

Under the hood

Nokia E61
Nokia E61
Enlarge »
O2 XDA Exec
O2 XDA Exec
Enlarge »
Then there's the issue of daily use. For instance, while all aspects of the Nokia E61 can be controlled solely by one hand, the Exec for the most part requires two. This problem is magnified by the voice dialing setup of the Exec, which is speaker dependent and doesn't work with Bluetooth headsets - a polar opposite to that of the E61, and something which makes for a marring user experience for talkative users. Meanwhile, both handsets deserve praise for their ability to serve up and refine matches for contacts while users are still typing in the search box, with the Exec being ever-so-slightly snappier than the E61.

O2 XDA Exec
O2 XDA Exec
Enlarge »
Nokia E61
Nokia E61
Enlarge »
Other aspects worthy of comparison include e-mail clients, where the E61 is solidly beat by the Exec; the former's approach squeezes sender and subject onto one line sans wrapping, often rendering the overview illegible through chopping the subject line prematurely. Also, as much as this puzzles us, the Pocket Internet Explorer browser of the Exec does a far better job than that of the E61 at reformatting ordinary web pages for mobile viewing - while the E61 excels at traversing full-size web pages without reformatting them.

Lastly, on the note of productivity, the office suite of the E61 manages to appear a few hairs better than Microsoft's own Pocket Office; the E61 may not synchronize documents with a desktop as effortlessly, but has better so-called roundtrip capabilities than Microsoft's homegrown solution. In plain English, that means the E61 is slightly better at editing documents without losing more advanced formatting - but keep in mind that the larger display of the Exec will show more data on-screen.

When push comes to shove

There's no denying that both the Nokia E61 and O2 XDA Exec are superbly powerful and capable devices - but despite their similar feature sets, there is enough of a difference to set the two apart. Heavy users of data aspects are likely to see their needs better served by the Exec, while the E61 will cater better to those whose usage pattern leans more towards voice.
Best Business smartphones
Name Score Price Carrier
C
AT&T Tilt 77% $400AT&T
HTC Mogul 73% $400Sprint
Nokia E71 73% $500Unlocked
Nokia E66 72% $500Unlocked
Motorola Q9h global 71% $250AT&T
Asus P527 68% $550Unlocked
T-Mobile Wing 67% $350T-Mobile
Samsung BlackJack II 67% $200AT&T
Motorola Q9c 67% $250Sprint
Palm Treo 800w (Sprint) 67% $350Sprint
Click here to see full and advanced chart »
 
 
 
RECOMMENDED
Digital Frontier:
CTIA hands-on blog
 
iPhone 3G vs. Omnia vs. Touch Diamond
 
Bold vs. Xperia X1 vs. Touch Pro vs. E71
TOP STORIES
Smartphones with WVGA, VGA or HVGA displays for high-res addicts
 
Hottest smartphones and cell phones coming in September
 
Four new phones are now shipping
Top 15 smartphones
 
Top 15 cell phones
 
15 best-rated phones
CELL PHONE RESOURCE CENTER
Best phones
 
Expert guides
 
Ask the Editors
» Top 15
QWERTY phones
 
All-touch phones
 
Touchscreen phones
Business phones
 
Multimedia phones
 
Concept phones
3+ inch screen phones
 
Wi-Fi phones
 
More...
» Search (New!)
Search by cell phone features
» Manual comparison (New!)
Select up to 4 cell phones side-by-side
» By release
September 2008, Q4 2008
» Top 15 by carrier
Unlocked, AT&T, Sprint, Verizon Wireless, T-Mobile, Helio, Alltel
» Top 15 by user type
Average Joe, Business users, Calling addicts, Fashion conscious users, Globetrotters, High-res addicts, Internet addicts, Multimedia enthusiasts, Music aficionados, Outdoor enthusiasts, TV addicts, Video lovers, More...
» Top 15 by brand
Apple, HTC, LG, Motorola, Nokia, BlackBerry, Samsung, Sony Ericsson Other
» Top 15 by platform
Palm OS, Symbian S60, Symbian UIQ, Windows Mobile
» Top 15 by cell phone type
Business smartphones, Multimedia smartphones
Consumer QWERTY phones, Multimedia phones
Concept phones
NOW IN PHONES
BlackBerry Curve 8330 vs. Palm Treo 800w vs. HTC Mogul
 
Samsung Airave review
 
Verizon Wireless Blitz review
 
Verizon Wireless Blitz video review
 
LG KC910 8-megapixel phone with all-touch interface
Windows Mobile 6.1 upgrade guide
Motorola Renegade V950, Motorola i365 picked up by Sprint
Smartphones with WVGA, VGA or HVGA displays for high-res addicts
Next 25 stories
MUST READ
CELL PHONES
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
LAPTOPS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
CAMERAS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
MP3 players
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
INTERNET TABLETS
» Coming soon
» Top 15
» Best-rated
GPS NAVIGATORS
HDTVs
CAMCORDERS
About us | Site map | How to advertise | Feedback | RSS Feeds | | Archive
Copyright 1999-2008 © infoSync World